Should I stay or should I go?
It’s that time of year again when Ohio State’s juniors decided if they are going to stay for one more season, or forgo their senior year to enter the NFL Draft.
Yesterday, when defensive end Vernon Gholston opted to play football on Sundays, I was not surprised. But when cornerback Malcolm Jenkins decided to stay one more year to play for the Buckeyes, I must say I am stunned.
While there are other juniors contemplating the same thing, it appears that there should be only one other junior that has a difficult decision to make, middle linebacker James Laurinaitis.
Of the six web sites I have visited offering their analysis of the 2008 NFL Draft, all three seem to be locks in the first round, if they do declare.
On Rivals.com, draft expert Frank Croyle lists his top 31 picks in the 2008 NFL Draft (note: there are only 31 first-round selections after the New England Patriots had to forfeit their pick due to SpyGate.) He has Laurinaitis going No. 7 to the aforementioned Patriots, Jenkins at No. 10 to the New Orleans Saints, and Gholston picked at No. 15 by his hometown Detroit Lions.
Croyle also states that “Jenkins looks like the No. 1 cornerback in this class.”
Croyle is also the only “expert” who has junior left tackle Alex Boone in the first round of any mock draft I have found, going to the Pittsburgh Steelers with their 24th-overall pick.
On Croyle’s web site, DraftInsiders.com, he states that “Launinaitis is an explosive player but still developing. He probably enters the draft and could be a top 10 selection with a strong workout. I love him but he is still raw in some key areas.”
At NFLDraftCountdown.com, has Gholston tabbed with the sixth pick going to the Oakland Raiders, while Laurinaitis is eighth by the Patriots, and Jenkins at No. 14 to the ‘Aints.
Scott Wright states that “Gholston isn’t merely a workout warrior because he has the production to go along with the measurables. Able to project to either defensive end in a 4-3 scheme or outside linebacker in a 3-4, Gholston would be an excellent fit in the Raiders defense.”
At FootballsFuture.com, Laurinaitis would be the seventh player selected by the Patriots, followed by Jenkins at No. 10 to the ‘Aints, and Gholston at No. 15 by the Lions.
Robert Davis points out that “after workouts, Gholston could go higher than this. He has the talent and production to be a prime pick.”
On DraftKing.com, Laurinaitis is sixth to the New York Jets, Jenkins 10th by the ‘Aints again, and Gholston the 13th-overall selection by the Carolina Panthers.
On NewNFLDraft.com, Laurinaitis is the seventh overall pick to the Patroits, Jenkins 10th to the ‘Aints, and Gholston 16th-overall pick by the Arizona Cardinals.
At NFLDraftDog.com, Gholston is listed seventh, Laurinaitis is ninth, and the only Jenkins listed is Mike, not Malcolm, a cornerback from South Florida.
One is going to have to assume that since this site does not include Malcolm Jenkins in their first round mock draft, that they have already taken him off the board, even though it says their rankings were updated on Janaury 3.
You almost have to wonder if Jenkins, a native of Piscataway, N.J., who has probably dreamt of playing pro football at the Meadowlands and kept seeing his name mentioned with the Saints, if that had any impact on his decision.
“It was a difficult decision, but he followed his heart and he followed his passion,” Gwendolyn Jenkins said of her son Friday night to Cleveland Plain Dealer sports reporter Doug Lesmerises. “I think it’s a decision he’s not going to regret. You would hate for kids to make a decision based on outside pressure and live to regret it.”
Though I can’t speak for Boone and Freeman, I will assume they will stay one more year. Wide receiver Brian Robiskie said he was staying, too.
Former Ohio State standouts Mike Doss and A.J. Hawk all stayed for their senior seasons under head coach Jim Tressel, maybe Laurinaitis could surprise us once again.
“When we played Florida, we looked slow,” Laurinaitis said in the same Plain Dealer article. “When we played LSU, we looked fast, we just made mental mistakes again and again. You look at the score and it looks like we don’t belong on the field, but we were really just a few momentum plays away.”
If Laurinaitis does return, and he has until Tuesday to make his decision, I will be looking forward to a much nicer vacation destination, next January.
































































